In the
end the losses and damage were;
Sunk or
sinking:- LCG(L) 1 & 2, LCF 37, LCG(M) 101 &
102. On
fire and abandoned:- LCF 38.
Damaged and out of action:- LCG(L) 11 & 17, LCT(R) 334 &
363, LCM 42 & 36, LCS(L) 260
Damaged but continuing:- LCG(L) 10, LCF 35 & 32, LCH 98.
The five
hour battle saw 172 killed and 236 wounded out of the little force. That their
sacrifice was not in vain was very evident as Operation Calendar got underway
on 3rd November, even before the island was fully taken. This was
the sweeping of the Scheldt for mines. In the
end 269 mines were removed and the navigation was declared open 25th
November. The first large ship to discharge in Antwerp
was the ‘Fort Cataraqui ’,
and soon the port was discharging 22000 tons of cargo a day which speeded the
run to the Rhine and ultimate victory in Europe .
There
were plenty of Honours handed out too. Commander Pugsley was awarded an OBE.
Commander K. Sellars was awarded a DSO. Two Royal Marine and twenty two Royal
Navy Officers were awarded the DSC and twenty seven RM and RN NCO’s were
awarded DSM’s.
After
the withdrawal at 1230 the majority of the SSEF withdrew to Ostend . HMS Kingsmill and LCH 269 remained
anchored 5 miles off the beach. Apparently the vessels that were anchored
received intelligence that they would be attacked by mini submarines and
frogmen so the order was given to drop explosives over the side every three
minutes. This could have been the incident that I remember Dad talking about,
rather than off the Normandy Beaches, until around 1345 when they too left the
field. The Warspite, Robert and Erebus withdrew for the night but were able to
offer further support the following day before leaving the area. It was to be
Warspite’s last action. She had fired 350 rounds of 15” shells between 0800 and
1800 on the 1st November, which is said by some to be the highest
number fired of any vessel. LCH 269 and a hospital craft were thought seaworthy
enough to continue to Poole. However the weather blew up and as the landing
craft were flat bottomed and high sided they made a lot off leeway. LCH 269
could also only steam at slow speed due to the hole in her bow. Unfortunately
the two vessels ended up in the English defensive mine field and they didn’t
have charts. The hospital vessel was struck amidships by a mine, lifted bodily
out of the water amidships and came down in two pieces and sank in seconds.
There were no survivors.
The LCH
269 was the only vessel to return to Poole unscathed. It was very sad to see
all the beds that would not be filled again. They were also very upset as some
of their personal possessions had been stolen. The vessels of the SSEF were
repaired over the next day before wending there way back to Poole. One of the
landing craft had 47 plugs in the hull to keep the water out.
Once the
survivors had returned to Poole and carried
out full repairs and maintenance and prepared the vessels for the next task
they were on stand by. Dad remained with the SSEF until 30th June
1945 but the small ships were not called to fight again. Dad must have been
billeted ashore around Poole or Portsmouth
but I have no way of knowing where. Earlier in 1945 the small fleet were told
to prepare their craft for the Far East as the
tide of conflict moved to the Pacific. They were never to go there though In
June and July the fleet of vessel were moved round to Appledore where they were
laid up for the long term and the remaining crews dispersed.
The only
vessel to return to Poole unscathed was LCH
269 and the 16 crew in the next few days decided to raise a fund for a memorial
for their fallen friends. Commander Sellars also chipped in a large amount. A
wooden plaque was erected outside St Michaels Church, Hamworthy, as the closest
to their base, until such time as material and money were available. The plan
was to build a lych-gate to the churchyard. It was not until early 1952 that
the Admiralty contacted the church and Commander Sellars visited with plans.
There was a scheme to enlarge the churchyard so the lych-gate would be
incorporated in this. The fund was still too small so the church agreed to fund
the base, brick pillars and curved wall whilst the Navy and Marines would find
the oak for the woodwork and pay for the two memorial stones that were to be
carved by local craftsmen. It was on 5th July that the Bishop of
Salisbury blessed the new churchyard and gate and the Royal Marine Band marched
up the road. Admiral Philip Vian and Commander Sellars were among the speech
makers and then over 200 enjoyed tea on the Rectory lawn. As far as I know it
should still be there.
Memorial Lych-Gate at St Michaels Church
Hamworthy
Memorial Plaque sited 5th July
1952
There
are two S206 personal report forms from his time in the SSEF. The first is
dated 30th April 1945 and so several months after the action at Walcheren . It is for recommendation for accelerated
promotion (Admiralty Fleet Order
4067/44). It states his position as Cypher and C.B. Officer. (I think that CB
is Confidential Books and were the codes of the day, orders and secret maps etc
that were for restricted viewing and were supposed to be kept in a weighted
pouch when not in use. It would have been Dad’s duty in a sinking or capture to
ensure that the pouch got thrown overboard to prevent them falling in to the
hands of the enemy). His general conduct is given as satisfactory (the only
other choice is unsatisfactory!). His habit is given as temperate.
Professional
Ability 7, Personal Qualities 6, Leadership 6, Intellectual Ability 6,
Administrative Ability 7. The general opinion of the Officer is ‘This young Officer has served for a
considerable period (as a rating) on various Admiral’s staffs and has knowledge
of procedure and customs of the service are wider than is usually found in the
Special Cypher Officers. His usefulness in the Squadron has been manifest in
many ways, and his willingness and ability to undertake duties not normally
expected of his branch, has been marked. He has good organising ability and, as
a cypherer, is in the first grade’.
He is
recommended for immediate promotion to Special Cypher, and it is signed by his
reporting officer Commander L.C.A. Leefe, RN, on 13th May 1945. Commander
Leefe was the Deputy Senior Commander of the Support Squadron, Eastern Flank. His
Senior Officer, Captain A.F. Pugsley, RN writes Forwarded, concurring and
signed 30th April 1945. Unless Captain Pugsley has made a mistake it
seems that he has originated the report as he dated his part prior to the
reporting Officer? This is a much better report than his previous one by a long
way so Dad must have acquitted himself well during the Battle or at least
during the reorganisation following.
There is
then a little mystery as only two weeks later, on 22nd May there is
almost the same report but this time his position is given as Squadron Cypher
and CB Officer. It seems that he got a sort of promotion as he is now looking
after the whole squadron. However this one is dated 22nd May by
Commander Leefe and 30th May by Capt. Pugsley. There is a further
mystery as the previous merits points have been crossed out and each lowered by
one and added in by hand. He is still recommended for immediate promotion
though. I wonder if they have reconsidered, or Dad has got bored after almost 6
months of doing not very much and got into trouble, or Commander Leefe liked him
less than Capt. Pugsley. We will never know now. I have also found a very short
report also written Commander Leefe which states Dad had conducted himself ‘to
my entire satisfaction. A keen, zealous and hardworking Officer. Always
cheerful and ready to undertake and duty asked of him’. I think this is a much
better report as it was shown to the Officer to which it was about rather than
the S206 form which was a confidential report and sent to the Admiralty.
Staff Officers, Support Squadron, Eastern
Flank. Probably taken in May 1945. (Dad 6th from left).
Left to Right; Sub. Lt. Robinson, C.O.C.O., Capt. Hiley-Jones
B.L.O., Lt. Taylor, S.R.M.O. Admin., Lt. Steel, Squadron Secretary, 2nd.
Off. Summer, Asst. Sec., Sub. Lt. Porter, S.C.Y.O., Lt. Comm. Leefe, D.S.C. S.S.E.F., Mr.
Hatfield, Bosun, Commander Sellar, C/O., S.S.E.F., Lt. McCormick, S.O.A., Capt.
Fisher RM, S.O.R.M., Lt. Legard, S.O.O., Lt. Eastwood, S.O.N., Lt. Thompson,
C.O.C.O., Sub. Lt. Douglas, Asst. S.C.Y.O.,
Mr. Toll, Gunner.
Officers of the Support Squadron, Eastern
Flank. Dad is at the far right on back row.
Inspection of
Support Squadron, Eastern Flank by Vice Admiral Sir Harold Burrough at Poole in
May 1945. Admiral Burrough was the Allied Naval Commander in Chief,
Expeditionary Force until July 1945.
The
above three photographs were taken by the Bournmouth Times. Some sources state
that the lower photograph was taken prior to the Walcheren Raid. Somebody has
written on the back of Dad’s photograph that it was taken in May 1945. The vessels
in the background are, from left to right, LCT(Flax)36, LCT(Gun) 536 (very
difficult to read but I have not been able to trace a number like this to the
Battle of Walcheren), LCT(Headquarters)269, ( I thought Dad may have been on this
vessel as it was the close-in HQ vessel with Commander Sellars aboard but on
balance as Dad was the Squadron Cypher Officer he was probably on the
Kingsmill). It is interesting to note though that he had an assistant, Sub. Lt
Douglas.
It looks
like the Support Squadron Eastern Flank was disbanded in June 1945 as the Officers that I can trace all
seemed to change postings at this time.
My dad was one of the surviving crew of the LCH 269. He was a coder. Bernard W. McCarthy. He survived the war and died in Glasgow in 1997 aged 84. He was born in Weymouth, Dorset in 1912. He never talked about his war experiences and suffered from depression for a lot of his adult life.
ReplyDeleteThanks for reading this blog. I don't look in on it that often so apologise for not replying earlier. It is a battle of the war I knew nothing about until I did this research. It must have been a very close quarters affair, which the RN were not really used to I suppose. My father only mentioned little of his experiences and never really in context. It is amazing how many of the veterans did manage to carry on with life afterwards. I hope your father managed to live a full life and his depression wasn't too debilitating.
DeleteMy grandad was on LCF38 at Walcheren. The one reported on fire and abandoned above! They were rescued by I think LCF 36 and tried to fight on until that too was damaged. I have read the report by Cdr Wilkes who was the captain of LCF38. By all accounts the battle was one of the worst of the war and the men were extremely brave and stoical. My grandad survived and lived until 1995. He never talked about his war time experiences so I knew nothing of this until recently. I am extremely proud of him, as I expect you are of your father. My heart goes out to them.
ReplyDeletePlease accept my apologise for not replying to your comment before, but this is the first time I have looked at the blog about my Dad for ages. When I started researching about my Dad I had never heard of Walcheren either. The more you look into it the more astounded I was that it went ahead at all. It shows how desperate they were to secure a port to sustain the advance that was stalling a little. My Dad was there but in the background as he was on the Admiral's staff. The men in the landing craft were at the sharp end, and to their eternal credit they came through and probably shortened the war for everybody. They were certainly a stoical lot in later life. It makes me realise that everybody has a story to tell, if you ask them.
ReplyDeleteKeep Well and thanks again for reading. Tony Porter
I'm curious if there are descendants of the parished crew of HMS LCG(M) 102. I was told there were no survivors. I've been diving on the wreck of this vessel near the coast at Westkapelle and I'd like to contact (a) descendant(s) of these brave men.
ReplyDelete